Embellishment or Thievery? How to Give Credit Where Credit Is Due

Tonya Kay - Pyragraph

In Los Angeles the walls have ears, I like to say. I discourage friends from shit-talking and bellowing out their creative ideas at cafes or even at my apartment because you never know who is listening. My neighbors alone are assistant directors, camera operators, musicians and more, working in fields as diverse as special effects, post-production and fashion design. And these folks aren’t fantasizing about those careers. These are real, working entertainment and creative arts professionals who make their living producing work that tours, screens, broadcasts, shows and sells.

I’ve actually seen a film story my best friend and I concepted get produced and distributed theatrically without consulting, inviting or crediting me (he got credit). I’ve had my writing published web-wide without author citing. I’ve had my photography show up on fliers promoting bands I don’t even know. I’ve had my costume designs appear on stage before I finished my own rhinestoning. I’ve had weirdos pattern their public personas after my personality and life hackers create social accounts posing as me.

It’s how we create and credit after inspiration that identifies us as honorable or as thieves.

This is all my creative property. My ideas, my talent and my personality are my commodities. So nowadays I use my inside voice for emotional rants and creative concepts. The walls have ears.

Many years ago, I was in a Chicago hip-hop class taught by Kirby Reed, a choreographer I admire. He addressed the concept of stealing another artist’s work with finesse when he busted out one of his signature moves. He said something like (I am paraphrasing—this was many years ago), “I know this move is gonna show up everywhere. If you can pay me; do. If you can’t pay me, then make me a legend by saying my name every time it’s used.” I did indeed use many of his moves in choreography for my students, but every time I did, I said, “This is the Kirby Reed.” My students knew his name as if he was famous. And to us, he absolutely was.

The longer I am a professional artist, the more I realize that people will be inspired by my art and I will be inspired by the work of others. It would be vain and egotistical to think that anything I create is genuinely original. We are always inspired by, riffing off of or embellishing something, whether the inspiration comes from a hike through Muir Woods, a sensual kiss from our lover, or a jaw-dropping Nine Inch Nails concert at Hollywood Bowl.

It’s how we create and credit after inspiration that identifies us as honorable or as thieves. And let’s face it, pay is great and puts food in an artist’s mouth. But accurate credit builds our future careers. And speaking our names to everyone creates legend status which gives influential privileges even after death.

Tonya Kay - Pyragraph

Here are some methods of creation coupled with appropriate crediting. In the end, remember that speaking the name of an artist costs nothing and offers legend status, which is always appreciated.

“Inspired By”

Artists and producers can be inspired by the morning sunlight as well as a conversation with their dad. Thank yous and shout outs are the appropriate recognition for inspiration. “Shout out to the blossoming jasmine, my inspiration for this next piece.”

Embellishment or Riffing

I actually did see Nine Inch Nails at Hollywood Bowl last week. Not only did I leave inspired in general, but specifically, the band used movable shadow screens I’d like to embellish in an act of mine. If I am taking any specific idea from another artist, it is required that I embellish it so much with my new concept that the other artist’s work is unidentifiable as the inspiration. This is called riffing or embellishing. If you do not embellish, then you are re-creating or just plain stealing. It’s appropriate in a situation like this to acknowledge and recognize the inspiration you’ve embellished. “I saw Trent Reznor use shadow screens at the Hollywood Bowl magnificently and that’s where this act started.”

Re-creation vs. Stealing

The difference between re-creating and stealing is entirely in the crediting of a work. Re-creation is when you take someone else’s work and cover it exactly—with credit. Stealing is when you take someone else’s work and cover it exactly—without credit. I have a dear burlesque friend who I watched steal another burlesque performer’s act verbatim without giving credit. My friend’s version was better because she’s a better performer and dancer, but that’s not embellishment—the act was performed verbatim and no credit was given, so it’s stealing.

I personally think the only reason to do a re-creation is in honor of the original show or artist. For example, I have a re-creation act of Gypsy Rose Lee’s 1943 performance in the film Stage Door Canteen. I’ve been in musical theater productions where we re-create the original Broadway choreography for the big production numbers to honor first production. And ALWAYS, when re-creating, the production cites the original choreographer in the program. Before my Gypsy Rose Lee re-creation, the emcee says exactly what I’m re-creating.

If you don’t give public credit for a re-creation, you are stealing. Which is tacky and risky because the walls have ears (and eyes) and someone is going to recognize your re-creation and you will look like you aren’t creatively competent.

Tribute

A tribute act is like an embellishment or riff, but instead of embellishing the act enough to make the inspiring concept unidentifiable, it is methodically keeping popular elements identifiable to benefit from and honor the reputation of the inspiring legend. Usually tributes are performed in honor of a legend (see my Lili St Cyr and Shirley Temple burlesque tribute acts) and crediting the legend is required ethically, plus it assists audience enjoyment through education and association. Again, a tribute is built on another artist’s popularity, so if you don’t credit them, you’ll look like an asshole professionally because their work is recognizable to much of the world.

Dedications

Dedications are works dedicated to someone or something. Dedications are defined by the credit of “dedicating this song to my late grandmother” or “dedicating this performance to the newly freed circus animals of Peru.” The work being dedicated can be any of the aforementioned creative methods and should be credited accordingly in addition to the offered dedication.

Some Final Thoughts on Ethics

Again, with certain artistic media, purchasing rights to reproduce, republish or cover is a clearly viable option and PAY is always the most honorable appreciation! But with performing arts like dance, burlesque, circus, comedy and other live stage shows, rights purchase is not always as clear, so ethics go a long way in one’s long-term professional reputation. A shout out, credit roll or permission request will keep you in good standing with the community and ensure a long-term devoted audience, hungry for your next creation!

Photos courtesy of Tonya Kay.
Originally published in Pyragraph Magazine

6 comments
  1. Johan

    February 26th, 2015 10:56

    Excellent message. Well said.

    Reply

  2. Ralph

    February 26th, 2015 18:10

    Lili VonSchtupp shared this, and it rolled across my feed, otherwise I might never have seen it. What a great piece, and one that translates so well across so very many genres. Bravo.

    Reply

    • Tonya Kay

      February 26th, 2015 18:59

      Ralph, thank you! And thank you, Lili – she’s been in the business so long and surely has encountered every aspect of tribute, embellishment and … other herself, I know. She’s a powerhouse of hosting prowess and I’ve always enjoyed working with her. Thank you for reading and sharing if you feel inspired.

      Reply

  3. John Doran (aka JackAffy)

    February 27th, 2015 9:35

    Tonya, you never fail to amaze me with your work, dedication, strength and ability to convey your thoughts and feelings. Truly, I’m seriuosly impressed…I just wish I lived in California. I’ve been wanting to ask this but, a little hesitant that it may come across as “creepy”.
    Are you married or otherwise involved in any way? Gad…..

    Reply

    • Tonya Kay

      February 28th, 2015 14:42

      Thank you for appreciating my work from a thoughtful eye and from the heart. Performance is what makes my spirit soar and to be appreciated is a connection between my audience and myself that I do not take for granted.

      And yes, I have a Lover, am loved the way I understand love to be.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *